There were no limits pre-2022. Back then, Justin was complaining about lists with 100,000 items in them.
I’m guessing that you’re misinterpreting Justin’s post from May 2022, which shows 250 (for new members) crossed out.
The crossed-out numbers weren’t existing limits, they were new limits being proposed at the time. Many users complained that such limits were excessive, so the following compromise was reached:
VIP Members
- Unlimited lists
- 10,000
2,000items on your watchlist- 10,000
2,000items on a personal listNew Members
- 5 personal lists
- 1,000
250items on your watchlist- 500
250items on a personal listExisting Members
- 10 personal lists
- 2,000
500items on your watchlist- 1,000
500items on a personal list
For long-time users such as myself, the watchlist limit has quite quickly dropped from theoretically infinite, to 2,000, to now just 100. I think saying that’s “a big drop” is a bit of an understatement.