Iām missing the links to e.g. TMDB .
4 Likes
if you type
trakt.tvand click sign in it will keep you at the v2 trakt. it doesnāt force you into the v3 model.
Are you saying if you click on any link generated here for trakt it still will always take you do the old V2 version of the website?
Iām logged in at the trakt.tv but for example if I click on your name and select to view your profile page, it automatically changes that to take me to the app.trakt.tv version of your profile instead of the old version.
In other words it takes me to Trakt Web: Profile instead of https://trakt.tv/users/otakunet21
Every single link generated is like that for me.
So from my persepective they are absolutely forcing V3/Lite on me. And with the return to the non-app webpage not being a single click back itās a royal PITA to be blunt to constantly have to go back to the main page and start over.
7 Likes
that is based on the add-on theyāve added to discourse that links to profiles. they used to link to the v2 ones but quickly changed it to v3. if you type it in just like i mentioned you should see the v2 site. and iām not talking about googling the site and clicking the link provided. type in trakt.tv and it should be the old v2 site
Oh I know that. Itās just ridiculously frustrating to constantly have to switch back and forth between versions. One should be allowed to choose a setting in preferences of what we want to use instead of having V3 / Lite with its incomplete usage and function being jammed down our throats.
10 Likes
mine never switches so im not sure whats happening with othersā. and ive tried it on multiple browsers on both my pc and my phone
the panic I felt when I couldnāt get to Classic Trakt, I hate app.trakt so so so much. Iāve reached my breaking point, goodbye VIP. These last few years were nice, itās a shame Trakt had to rebrand itself into absolute shit. Wow.
17 Likes
I cannot believe they keep trying to force this on us while it looks like this. Do the designers and developers take no pride at all in their work?
12 Likes
Hopefully devs are still watching this thread for feedback. I just got the auto-redirect to the app version, where you need to manually type ā/dashboardā to go back to the old one.
Iām a web developer and there are still a lot of UI/UX problems when browsing on desktop, and some general changes that bother me personally.
As a frame of reference, the main things I do on this site are check for upcoming episodes of shows Iām watching, or mark recently-watched shows and movies as Watched, either under Continue Watching or by searching. I donāt favourite, I donāt socialize, I donāt comment unless somethingās irregular with the listing, I donāt add things to collections or even know what ācheck inā means. But Iāve been using this site daily for probably a decade.
I browse on my Windows desktop with Waterfox (as of a couple weeks ago when I switched from Firefox) or Opera GX, or very rarely on my Android phone in Chrome.
- The media filters at the top donāt work, and donāt seem particularly useful. Thereās a disabled āFilterā button in the corner, and I donāt see why these buttons wouldnāt just be an extension of that.
- The left-side navbar is an extremely irregular choice. AppleTV-style apps for use with a remote control have similar designs, but typically still have labels and are more top-left-aligned than left-side and centered. The current position is uncommon to reach with a mouse and feels awkward. Every one of those apps has a browser version with a classic navbar at the top. Collapse the Movie/Show filter into the Filters and move your icon bar up there, left-aligned (with nice margins) near the logo and VIP button, with text next to the icons.
- Home/Dashboard being the second option is very disorienting, and also feels like mimicking the UX of a wildly different type of device. On browsers and mobile apps, the default option is expected to be the first one. I keep clicking the searchbar when trying to get back to the homepage. It should be placed first, and another search button should be added closer to the logo at the top of the page, as thatās the main action most people will do when they access the site. (āIāve just watched something, time to log it in Traktā)
- In Waterfox (same engine as Firefox), my Continue Watching has a horizontal scrollbar, and the extra height adds a 1-pixel vertical scrollbar. It seems thereās an
overflow-x: autothatās being introduced on@supports (-moz-appearance: none) { .section-list-container.section-list-has-drilldown.svelte-1rbin7o .section-list-horizontal-scroll:where(.svelte-1rbin7o)for some reason. This introduces inconsistent behaviour and looks bad. - I prefer the posters for the shows over the individual episode preview images, which can contain spoilers. I see search results are still showing the posters that way. It would be nice to be able to toggle these and show the posters again, even if it significantly increases screen height.
- More text on the shows should be hyperlinks. Also, the search results should display the name of the show in text. On Continue Watching, I keep expecting to be able to click on the show name, season number, episode number, and episode name, and go to appropriate places based on each.
- For some reason a bunch of dropped shows from my past are now showing up under Continue Watching, greyed out. I think I muted them before ādrop showā was a proper option, so maybe I have to formalize that more. Not necessarily a problem, but just surprising. Hitting Enter on the ādrop show?ā pop-up seems to cancel, rather than confirm. It would be nice to have a quicker way to do this, seeing as I now have to more concretely re-drop a bunch of shows.
- I miss some of the stats. The daily breakdown of how much Iāve watched over the last month was fun, and I enjoyed bragging to friends when I would mark a whole show at once and tell them that I watched 72 hours of something in one day.
- I miss a lot of the date-based grouping. Having my Upcoming Schedule grouped by days gave a better view at a glance of which days had which shows. Listing them by day of the week is important for me planning which shows will be out on the nights I watch with friends or family. Displaying the time, platform, and special notes (premiere/finale) was helpful for a lot of planning as well. Randomized quirky messages on open days are an unnecessary distraction and donāt make me enjoy the site more, Iād prefer a more upfront āNo Upcoming Shows.ā or something.
- The overridden scrollbar in Chromium browsers is an accessibility issue, people arenāt going to realize they can scroll because the bar only appears when itās moused over and itās narrower than usual. It also feels odd that the filters at the top arenāt stuck in place when scrolling.
- Something about the background just feels lacking. Itās a grey site with things floating in it. A small separator line between some of the components would add a bit more of a structured feeling, or at least a visual change between the panels and the navbars. Maybe a gradient behind one background, and a flat colour behind the show panels and text, that would give a satisfying visual separation between them while still being responsive and modern.
- I didnāt realize at first that clicking the different seasons of a show was updating the list of episodes being shown. Perhaps the upper panel should say āSeasonsā and list them, then below that it should say which season is currently displayed, above the episode list.
- Have we lost the āwatch all remainingā option on Continue Watching? Iād be fine with it under the three-dot menu, but Iāll often catch up on a show all at once and only mark it in Trakt once Iām finished.
Positives:
- I like being able to mark a new episode as watched with a single click.
- I havenāt tried it yet, but the queue feature could be nice. I have a big text document of shows and movies and it may be convenient to have that duplicated here.
- I think the JustWatch integration is pretty sleek. If possible, the ability to change which countryās sources are displayed would be helpful, as Iām often coordinating shows with both American and Canadian friends.
Now that Iāve used it a bit more while writing this message, Iām over a lot of the UX shock that accompanies a big change like this. I still think all of the points I listed above are important and should be considered, and almost every big UI redesign like this is a mistake, but I can deal with the redesign and will continue using the site, hoping it will improve over time.
7 Likes
Youāre giving a lot of good insight, I would recommend also leaving a feedback thread or opening multiple issues in their GitHub repo since devs most times respond directly over there
How do I load the new page? I just get a blank screen when going to trakt.tv now:
1 Like
I just tried looking at the v3 trakt link you attached for your profile, and for some reason it reloads every single second. This really is super annoying, I wish they would scrap this new version and stick to the far better older version.
7 Likes
Iāve been paying for the VIP not because I wanted this label, but because I wanted to support the developers. Now I can state that the new trakt is totally unusable. The minimalistic UI hurts my eyes, it looks like a mobile app opened on a desktop. All my 1-10 scale ratings are now 1-5, which makes little to no sense to me. I want to use a desktop website, not a minimalistic something on a 16ā screen. I hope the developers will allow us to use the old website, I donāt need new features, I want it to just work. Otherwise I quit, sorry. It was nice 3 years together, but now youāve destroyed everything I loved so much. Just why? If people want to use a website optimized only for iphone, I donāt. And again, how could you change the rating system to 1-5 when people have been using 10-grade system for years? How should we adapt to this? So many questions.
21 Likes
I was blissfully unaware of Lite until 30 minutes ago when the Android app updated and I checked the website and suddenly I had no idea how to do things I wanted to do. My reaction is that Trakt now looks and behaves like every other website, and that it has lost what made it special, the details that made it appeal to nerds and geeks. Presumably the new design will attract a broader audience, but Iām guessing itās the nerds and geeks who were paying to be VIPs. Iām going to play around to see if thereās still a way to filter by streaming service, etc. If not I might as well use free Just Watch. Unless there will be something new rolling out for VIP membership that will differentiate Trakt.
21 Likes
The announcement sais that āclassicā Trakt (aka. the one I paid for) is till available during the transition.
I canāt seem to be able to access classic Trakt any longer.
How can I please access classic Trakt?
Or is the transition to the āLite UIā over? And how did I miss the corresponding announcement?
Just use this URL Discover. Track. Share. - Trakt
8 Likes
Holy moly just saw this today, all my apps updated and useless, website redirects to new one unless you force some action to the old one? It looks horrendous and is totally unusable, and not in the ātakes time to adjustā kind of way. You canāt even scroll through the episodes on a show if you donāt have a trackpad or mouse with side scrolling? Why are the Reviews and Extraās above the seasons and episodes? Every action is just an icon with no hover text to see what it actually does?
10 Likes
V3 is nothing like the Trakt I signed up for, please do not force it upon me.
13 Likes
This is actually the best description Iāve heard so far. I get the need to modernize the platform and if you want to, yes, unify UI between devices, itās all fair. But as you said, v3 is not for the nerds and geeks anymore. Itās lacking information density and all of the tiny features that made Trakt so loved by many people. And yes, theyāre slowly adding back features and everything, and Iām sure most of it will come back, but having a platform with most of the features but missing all of the small stuff is not what will please year-long Trakt users.
5 Likes
I understand the redesign of your app and site.
What I dont understand is forcing it to everybody while itās missing a lot of features that we are using.
Where are all my settings on web? Why canāt I view the calender on the app? This is why Iām paying for VIP for years.
This should still be in beta, you should only push it to production when the same features are present or its improved. None of it applies right now.
13 Likes
