Uncombine Netflix Documentaries

I am unsure if this is the place to post this, if not please move it or redirect me to the proper category.

IMDb decided to combine 3 Netflix documentaries into 1 series. These being:

  1. Dahmer - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story
  2. Monster: The Ed Gein Story
  3. Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story

While these do belong in a ‘Monster’ anthology, they are not 1 series. They are not shown or advertised as seasons, only mentions of “From the same creators of …”. When you go on Netflix and search for them, they are displayed as 3 different entries and not under seasons of 1 show.

I believe these 3 documentaries should either be kept as 3 distinctive series or if you wish to keep them together at least called it ‘Monster’ because it makes so sense to have the other 2 as seasons under ‘Dahmer - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story’ when they have nothing to do with Dahmer.

1 Like

Trakt imports data from TMDB for shows and TMDB has a say how they store their series based on their TMDB bible.

they claim it’s separate series and nothing will change that unfortunately.

I think you’re talking about this one.

This is a bad entry that was removed from TMDB and currently is an orphan on trakt.

@Sonply do you think this one should be removed? Or is there a reason to keep this one?

The following are what is still linked to TMDB.

1 Like

TMBD displays them as 3 completely different shows.

  1. Monster: The Ed Gein Story (TV Series 2025-2025) — The Movie Database (TMDB)
  2. Monsters: The Lyle and Erik Menendez Story (TV Series 2024-2024) — The Movie Database (TMDB)
  3. DAHMER - Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story (TV Series 2022-2022) — The Movie Database (TMDB)

It’s IMDb that doesn’t. They now display it just under ‘Monster’.

  1. Monster (TV Series 2022– ) - IMDb

Netflix still shows them as 3 different series. Trakt is able to migrate the page to TMBD and separate the data of each season as a different shows. I requested they do the opposite with I am Groot when IMDb decided to separate each episode into movies for some odd reason and Trakt was able to adjust, I don’t see why they can’t for this.

Trakt does too. I just linked the three separate series.

Theres one that is combined which is an orphan because TMDB deleted their entry which I think should be deleted from Trakt.

Ahh I see, so they are 3 different series on Trakt, it’s just the Old Dahmer entry is now a series combining all 3. Trakt needs to delete it and merge the watched data to the new one?

Yep. The combined one is a “bad” one which TMDB already removed from their end which I believe trakt didn’t get around to removing it yet. You can tell because if you go on the website, there’s a TMDB link.

If you click it and it shows a “page cannot be found” then it’s an orphan trakt entry and technically should be deleted.

The TMDB link for the individual monster show actually goes to the TMDB page so it means it’s correctly active and linked properly to TMDB.

We will wait and see what trakt support says in the morning when they wake up. I’ve tagged one of them and he’s pretty responsive once he’s online.

Thank you.

to be fair, I think this change happened within the last 2 hours because I was watching shows and marking them watched. Then boop, out of nowhere Dahmer came back up on my Up Next and I was so confused haha

Yea it originally screwed me up in the past too after I started the second series when it was released.

Since then, I removed the watches from that combined one and used the single season ones instead for tracking my watches.

I’ve merged the data of the page that had the 3 seasons with the 3 individual shows.
We list the shows as they list on TMDB and what matters there is how they originally aired. So if they have 3 different pages for them on Netflix, that’s how we list them.

1 Like